 |
Brothers: The Hidden History of the Kennedy Years by David Talbot
Book Summary InformationAuthor: David Talbot Edition: Paperback Audio: English (Published) Format: Bargain Price Published: 2008-06-03 ISBN: N/A Number of pages: 496 Publisher: Free Press
Book Reviews of Brothers: The Hidden History of the Kennedy YearsBook Review: Talbot's attempt to weigh in on the conspiracy hegemony... Summary: 3 Stars
I'm still torn about this work by David Talbot...having read it when it first appeared in 2007, I'm impressed with the research and compulsion with which Talbot dispassionately presents his view of the JFK and RFK coalescence. What I feel is irresponsible is the manner in which Talbot forwards the conspiracy amalgam both in JFK's and RFK's assassination and the lurid notion that they were related. With the overture of "recently released documentation" (the conspiracy theorists manifesto), Talbot attempts to dissuade (whether overtly or covertly) those of us who view these events as actions by madmen and in the process seriously detracts from an otherwise courageous endeavor to further the written word on a fascinating period in American history.
Talbot must be accorded his due in presenting the heretofore unclear undertakings of RFK following the assassination of his brother and his understandable estimations that activities launched by he and his brother during the preceding three years went too far and resulted in this tragedy. The key argument here is that RFK initiated this investigation into his brother's death and found NOTHING in the following five years in terms of substantial evidence to overturn the Warren Commission Report. Talbot's obligation then, in my opinion, is to merge this unsuccessful attempt at determining a conspiracy (from possibly the person with the most resources to uncover a conspiracy) into a cohesive report that concludes with overwhelming evidence that Oswald acted alone thus ending these absurd conspiracy notions. Whether overcome by emotion or events (maybe even money?), Talbot chooses otherwise and does nothing more than add to the confusion, thus making this work substandard.
It's truly a pity because otherwise, this work adds much to the history of the JFK administration and, moreover, to the elusive understanding of what RFK went through following this violent nexus. Following him through to his own assassination, we see RFK turn from the "ruthless" Attorney General into a compassionate proponent of human and civil rights who becomes increasingly outraged at the continuance of the Vietnam War. Creating his own persona, he runs for the Senate in New York and the presidency in 1968 while presenting an attractive alternative to the myriad of Washington types also running for president. His assassination at the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles destroys these dreams and fuels the indignation present in the country during the turbulent late sixties. Talbot covers these events with compunction while bemoaning the loss of a great leader. I like many others (I'd wager) devoured this estimable report of the tragic events, but become increasingly disenchanted with his final chapter and the conclusions that these "new documents" present...all told, we understand that RFK made many attempts to dissect his brother's murder and could not uncover any substantial evidence to counter the Warren Commission. Talbot concludes that new evidence is now present and further scrutiny is in order, thus leaving the door open to the conspiracy community. The problem is that Talbot presents nothing new other than the fact that RFK "seemed" to withdraw into this "search" For these reasons, this book suffers the animus that several less erudite accounts also acclaim.
Certainly a well written account and, in most cases, a balanced and reasoned look at the JFK/RFK years...David Talbot is successful in researching and presenting a formidable history but leans heavily towards the conspiracy community with no new evidence and attempts to put words and actions in RFK's mouth that I feel weren't and never should be there.
Summary of Brothers: The Hidden History of the Kennedy YearsFor decades, books about John or Robert Kennedy have woven either a shimmering tale of Camelot gallantry or a tawdry story of runaway ambition and reckless personal behavior. But the real story of the Kennedys in the 1960s has long been submerged -- until now. In Brothers: The Hidden History of the Kennedy Years, David Talbot sheds a dramatic new light on the tumultuous inner life of the Kennedy presidency and its stunning aftermath. Talbot, the founder of Salon.com, has written a gripping political history that is sure to be one of the most talked-about books of the year.Brothers begins on the shattering afternoon of November 22, 1963, as a grief-stricken Robert Kennedy urgently demands answers about the assassination of his brother. Bobby's suspicions immediately focus on the nest of CIA spies, gangsters, and Cuban exiles that had long been plotting a violent regime change in Cuba. The Kennedys had struggled to control this swamp of anti-Castro intrigue based in southern Florida, but with little success. Brothers then shifts back in time, revealing the shadowy conflicts that tore apart the Kennedy administration, pitting the young president and his even younger brother against their own national security apparatus. The Kennedy brothers and a small circle of their most trusted advisors -- men like Theodore Sorensen, Robert McNamara, and Kenneth O'Donnell, who were so close the Kennedys regarded them as family -- repeatedly thwarted Washington's warrior caste. These hard-line generals and spymasters were hell-bent on a showdown with the Communist foe -- in Berlin, Laos, Vietnam, and especially Cuba. But the Kennedys continually frustrated their militaristic ambitions, pushing instead for a peaceful resolution to the Cold War. The tensions within the Kennedy administration were heading for an explosive climax, when a burst of gunfire in a sunny Dallas plaza terminated John F. Kennedy's presidency. Based on interviews with more than one hundred fifty people -- including many of the Kennedys' aging "band of brothers," whose testimony here might be their final word on this epic political story -- as well as newly released government documents, Brothers reveals the compelling, untold story of the Kennedy years, including JFK's heroic efforts to keep the country out of a cataclysmic war and Bobby Kennedy's secret quest to solve his beloved brother's murder. Bobby's subterranean search was a dangerous one and led, in part, to his own quest for power in 1968, in a passion-filled campaign that ended with his own murder. As Talbot reveals here, RFK might have been the victim of the same plotters he suspected of killing his brother. This is historical storytelling at its riveting best -- meticulously researched and movingly told. Brothers is a sprawling narrative about the clash of powerful men and the darker side of the Cold War -- a tale of tragic grandeur that is certain to change our understanding of the relentlessly fascinating Kennedy saga.
Political Books
|
 |