 |
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Peter David, Robin Furth, Stephen King Brand: Marvel Illustrator: Jae Lee Edition: Hardcover Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Published: 2007-11-21 ISBN: 0785121447 Number of pages: 240 Publisher: Marvel
Book Reviews of Dark Tower: The Gunslinger BornBook Review: Not worth your time Summary: 2 Stars
I cannot speak to Stephen King's Dark Tower novels themselves--I've never read them--but the graphic novel adaptation "The Gunslinger Born" is not worth your time. Here's why:
Let's start at the very beginning. Although I have read works that successfully use foreign words and phrases to enrich the text and evoke a sense of strangeness to the reader, this is not one of them. As presented, the narrator's use of such phrases as "do ya kennit?" "I know ye ken," and "thankee, sai," are not interesting, nor are they simply jarring. They are annoying.
In fact, throughout the pages of The Gunslinger Born, the narrator himself becomes rather annoying--certainly not someone I would willingly sit around and listen to for any length of time.
The story revolves around Roland Deschain, the Gunslinger, and the first foray he and his friends make from their sheltered lives into the conflicts and conspiracies of Mid-World. The most disappointing aspect: despite the obvious conflicts portrayed, it is certain there are really no challenges for Roland and his friends to overcome, because there are no failures which must be conquered in order for them to succeed. Witness: Even as mere children aged between 15 and 16 and despite rampant naivete, Roland and his friends easily outwit, outmaneuver and outgun large numbers of men with far more worldly experience. My disbelief was NOT suspended.
And then there is the artwork. A casual flip through this graphic novel will at first reveal seemingly beautiful artwork--heavy shadows and contrasting (though muted) tones along with sparse and significant use of certain colors. The style catches your eye, and is very atmospheric; however, upon reading the story and becoming immersed in that atmosphere, the overuse of these techniques becomes a hefty burden upon the whole. Though the artwork admittedly succeeds at creating the appropriate "darkness" within which to envelope the reader and relate the tale of the gunslinger's origins, the overuse of the very elements that create that atmosphere, specifically the shadows, also succeed at making the artwork appear dull and flat.
Exacerbating the style issue, the manner in which the characters are drawn makes them appear static, especially when they are conversing or something *dramatic* is happening. Quite often, the illustrations give the impression you are looking at a pretentious magazine model posing for dramatic effect. Witness the introduction of Farson, one of the story's much feared villains: On a two-page spread split horizontally into two panels, we see the *fearsome* Farson depicted first straight-on and then as a direct right-side profile--both elementary means of depiction, neither of them dramatic. If you met this Farson, you'd yawn.
Worse still, the characters are also often depicted devoid of expression, yet when there are expressions conveyed--facial expressions, body language and posture, etcetera--they often contradict the actions occurring or what a character is saying within the panel. Witness the opening, full-page panel to Chapter Four: Susan Delgado is depicted as serene, although her stallion is clearly harried and rippling with intensity. The narrator tells us she is "Galloping...as if to outrun her own thoughts." A girl in her manner astride a horse as depicted would be thrown, `nuff said.
Each of the above issues manages to deflate intensity right out of the story--as if there was a lot of story to begin with, but that is another matter.
In short, based on this first entry (and although I already own the second Dark Tower graphic novel), I recommend avoiding this series.
Summary of Dark Tower: The Gunslinger Born"The man in black fled across the desert, and the gunslinger followed." With those words, millions of readers were introduced to Stephen King's Roland -- an implacable gunslinger in search of the enigmatic Dark Tower, powering his way through a dangerous land filled with ancient technology and deadly magic. Now, in a comic book personally overseen by King himself, Roland's past is revealed! Sumptuously drawn by Jae Lee and Richard Isanove, adapted by long-time Stephen King expert Robin Furth (author of Stephen King's The Dark Tower: A Concordance) and scripted by New York Times Best-seller Peter David, this series delves deep into Roland's origins -- the perfect introduction to this incredibly realized world, while long-time fans will thrill to adventures merely hinted at in the novels. Be there for the very beginning of a modern classic of fantasy literature! "The man in black fled across the desert, and the gunslinger followed." With those words, millions of readers were introduced to Stephen King's Roland - an implacable gunslinger in search of the enigmatic Dark Tower, powering his way through a dangerous land filled with ancient technology and deadly magic. Now, in a comic book personally overseen by King himself, Roland's past is revealed! Sumptuously drawn by Jae Lee and Richard Isanove, adapted by long-time Stephen King expert Robin Furth (author of Stephen King's The Dark Tower: A Concordance) and scripted by New York Times bestseller Peter David, this series delves in depth into Roland's origins - the perfect introduction to this incredibly realized world; while long-time fans will thrill to adventures merely hinted at in the novels. Be there for the very beginning of a modern classic of fantasy literature! Collects Dark Tower: The Gunslinger Born #1-7. Questions for The Dark Tower Illustrators, Peter David and Robin Furth Amazon.com: How closely did you work with Stephen King on this project? Peter David: Robin worked far more closely with Steve before the fact, as it were, working out the overall story arcs and beats. My association was more after the fact: I wrote the scripting, which then went to King who provided the line edits and tweaks. Robin Furth: I?ve been working with Steve King (and Roland!) for about seven years now, so the three of us have quite a long history. While working on The Gunslinger Born, I ran my outlines by Steve King and Chuck Verrill (Steve?s editor) at the same time that I ran them by our Marvel editors. After all, The Dark Tower is Steve?s child so it?s only right for him to have first dibs on any changes. I feel it?s really important that Steve has final say about The Long Road Home. Hence, I always try to make sure he sees everything as soon as I can send drafts to him, and that includes the articles I write and which are at the end of each issue. Steve has been really supportive of this whole project which has been great. I was lucky enough to be with Steve while he looked through some of Jae?s early sketches for The Gunslinger Born and his reaction was a lot like mine?it felt as though somebody had reached into his imagination and had taken his characters and given them a physical existence. I think that?s pretty high praise, don?t you? Amazon.com: Roland is one of the most iconic characters King has ever created. How hard was it to get him (and the other characters) "right" on the page? Did any iterations get vetoed by King? Robin Furth: We were really lucky with The Gunslinger Born because we could adapt scenes directly from Wizard and Glass. We could really stick to Steve?s descriptions. (Occasionally we dipped into other Dark Tower novels, but on the whole, Wizard and Glass was our template.) The Long Road Home was a little more complicated since we spun the story from scattered tales that Roland tells about his youth?stories that are found throughout the Dark Tower books. (As you can imagine, I used my Concordance quite a lot while I was working on the outlines!) To tell the truth, Roland has such a strong personality that he feels almost human. I even dream about the guy, and once or twice I swear I?ve seen his shadow pacing past my writing room door. (No joke.) But even when it comes to writing about someone you know well, every person has their own perspective. As long as Steve King feels like we?ve caught Roland?s youthful self, I?m happy. If longtime Dark Tower fans feel we have, then I?ll be INCREDIBLY happy. So far Steve has been pleased with our approach. Fingers crossed that the fans will feel the same way! Peter David: King was very supportive of the license we took in terms of both the story compression and narrative stylizations that Robin and I undertook that were required to take a work of such massive scope and transform it into something that works as a graphic series. Amazon.com: What was the most challenging aspect of this particular project? Peter David: For me? Stage fright. Steve had stated that, as "a words guy," he was awaiting the scripts with great anticipation. That's pretty daunting, knowing that Stephen King is going to be going over my interpretation of what is arguably is most personal work. Robin Furth: I suppose the biggest challenge has always been (in Mid-World speak) to stand true. In other words, to remain true to our original mission and to translate the Dark Tower universe from novel form to comic book form. The Dark Tower universe is so big that we have to do a lot of condensing. It?s both scary and exhilarating. Amazon.com: Robin, I imagine it is challenging to fit a several thousand page series into a graphic novel. As the DT aficionado, was it hard to adapt this series? What parts of the book did you wish you could include but had to cut because it just wouldn?t fit? Robin Furth: It certainly has been challenging (you should see the state of my fingernails), but it has also been a really great experience. I have learned huge amounts about comics and about storytelling. I have always loved Roland, Alain, Cuthbert, and Susan so it has been wonderful to work with them again. There?s something very moving about working with young Roland?the boy who grew into such a hard and (at times) unforgiving man. You see the wounds that later become calluses, if you know what I mean. As for the parts of the book I had to cut?there are many! When we first started working on these comics, The Gunslinger Born was supposed to be six issues long. I handed in eight issues! In the end we managed to cut back to seven, which worked well. In retrospect, I guess the greatest challenge has been to know when to stick to the plot of Wizard and Glass and when to borrow from other books (or occasionally even other parts of the Dark Tower universe) in order to fill out Mid-World for those who don?t know the novels, or to make the comics ring true for long-term fans. That takes a lot of careful planning and sometimes it means taking risks, but if it works it?s really worth it. Amazon.com: Peter, What was it like to work with Robin and King on this project? Have you worked closely with writers before on adaptations of their work? Peter David: It was both exciting and daunting: exciting being part of something as ambitious and potentially groundbreaking as this endeavor, and daunting in that King is a writing god whom I desperately wanted to please with my interpretations. No, I've never worked with a writer adapting his work before, which is why this was new territory for me: And what a place to start, huh? It's difficult to imagine any subsequent experience with adapting someone's work measuring up to this. Amazon.com: What is your favorite panel? Robin Furth: I must say I like them all, so I don?t know if I could choose. However Jae recently sent me the cover for the first issue of The Long Road Home, and I think that would be in my top ten! Peter David: I'm torn on that. In terms of story narrative, the one where Roland and Susan give in to their passion. In terms of pure iconic power, that two-page spread early on where we first see Roland, as the gunslinger, in pursuit of the man in black. You never have a second chance to make a good first impression, and Jae and Richard just absolutely nailed it.
Fantasy Books
|
 |
Stephen King's Dark Tower Vol. 1: The Gunslinger Bornby Peter David, Robin Furth, Richard Isanove Marvel; Marvel Books; Published: 2010-12-15; Paperback; BookBest price: $4.32Price in other shops: $17.99
Essential Peter Parker, The Spectacular Spider-Man, Vol. 2 (Marvel Essentials)by Bill Mantlo, Tom Defalco, Roger Stern, Marv Wolfman, Tony Isabella, Ralph Macchio, David Kraft Marvel; Marvel; Published: 2006-02-08; Paperback; BookBest price: $12.13Price in other shops: $16.99
Essential Killraven Volume 1: War Of The Worlds TPBby Roy Thomas, Gerry Conway, Marv Wolfman, Don McGregor, Bill Mantlo, Neal Adams, Keith Giffen, Joseph Michael Linsner, Howard Chaykin, Herb Trimpe, Rich Buckler, Gene Colan, Craig Russell, Sal Buscema Marvel Comics; Published: 2005-07-20; Paperback; BookBest price: $6.83Price in other shops: $16.99
Essential Tomb of Dracula, Vol. 2 (Marvel Essentials)by Marv Wolfman Marvel Comics; Published: 2004-04-21; Paperback; BookBest price: $23.00
Naruto 2009 Wall Calendarby LLC Andrews McMeel Publishing Andrews McMeel Publishing; Published: 2008-07-01; Calendar; BookBest price: $4.40Price in other shops: $13.99
Mort Big Comic (Discworld)by Terry Pratchett Victor Gollancz; Published: 1994-12; Paperback; BookBest price: $325.56
xxxHOLiC, Vol. 17by CLAMP Del Rey; Published: 2011-09-13; Paperback; BookBest price: $6.07Price in other shops: $10.99
Mercy Thompson: Homecomingby Patricia Briggs Del Rey/Dabel Brothers; Published: 2009-08-25; Hardcover; BookBest price: $2.98Price in other shops: $23.00
Take a ChanceDel Rey/Dabel Brothers; Paperback; Book
Flight, Volume FourVillard; Published: 2007-07-10; Comic; BookBest price: $15.13Price in other shops: $24.95
|
Dark Tower: The Fall of Gilead (Dark Tower (Marvel Paperback))by Stephen King, Peter David, Robin Furth, Richard Isanove Marvel; Published: 2011-11-02; Paperback; BookBest price: $10.66Price in other shops: $19.99
Dark Tower, Vol. 3: Treacheryby Robin Furth, Peter David Marvel; Marvel; Published: 2011-03-16; Paperback; BookBest price: $6.00Price in other shops: $19.99
Stephen King's Dark Tower, Vol. 2: The Long Road Homeby Peter David, Robin Furth, Richard Isanove Marvel; Published: 2010-10-20; Paperback; BookBest price: $8.92Price in other shops: $19.99
Dark Tower: The Gunslinger: The Battle of Tull (The Dark Tower: the Gunslinger)by Stephen King, Peter David, Robin Furth Marvel; Published: 2012-01-25; Hardcover; BookBest price: $12.99Price in other shops: $24.99
Dark Tower: The Gunslinger, Vol. 1 - The Journey Beginsby Stephen King, Robin Furth, Peter David Marvel; Published: 2011-01-26; Hardcover; BookBest price: $15.64Price in other shops: $24.99
Dark Tower: The Fall of Gileadby Stephen King, Peter David, Robin Furth Marvel; Marvel; Published: 2010-02-17; Hardcover; BookBest price: $12.98Price in other shops: $24.99
Dark Tower: The Battle of Jericho Hillby Peter David, Robin Furth Marvel; Published: 2010-08-18; Hardcover; BookBest price: $13.95Price in other shops: $24.99
Dark Tower: Treacheryby Stephen King, Robin Furth, Peter David Marvel Books; Published: 2009-04-21; Hardcover; BookBest price: $11.92Price in other shops: $24.99
Dark Tower: The Long Road Home (Exclusive Amazon.com Cover)by Stephen King, Peter David, Robin Furth, Richard Isanove Marvel Books; Published: 2008-10-07; Hardcover; BookBest price: $9.50Price in other shops: $24.99
Dark Tower: The Gunslinger - The Little Sister of Eluriaby Stephen King Marvel; Marvel; Published: 2011-06-22; Hardcover; BookBest price: $12.49Price in other shops: $24.99
|