 |
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Jeffrey Archer Edition: Mass Market Paperback Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Published: 2009-12-01 ISBN: 0312539525 Number of pages: 448 Publisher: St. Martin's Paperbacks
Book Reviews of Paths of GloryBook Review: Identity Theft in a Fairy Tale Setting Summary: 1 Stars
Is this a new trend? A recent blockbuster film--"Sherlock Holmes"--in which Holmes is not the prissy gentleman detective created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, but a slovenly 1960's hippy, and Dr Watson is no longer a bumbling senior citizen, but a very dapper younger man. The two trade snarky insults with all the fervor of a friendship that cannot say its name.
But at least Sherlock Holmes was fictional! Now along comes Jeffery Archer and recreates a revered historical figure, George Mallory of Everest, that also bares no resemblance to the personality and career of the actual figure. This artistic license might work if he had painted an interesting portrait of this complicated man and his tragic drive to conquer the world's highest peak, but the portrait that results is a complete soap opera rewrite. His detailed descriptions of Mallory's teammates, their camp site palaver, even the geography of the mountain, will make anyone cringe who has even a passing acquaintance with this famous saga.
Mallory was an earnest Boy Scout riding the social coattails of his Alpine and literary acquaintances. He was too personally disorganized ever to be a leader of men, nor did he have the interpersonal toughness for the job. The Alpinists respected him for his astonishingly skill at rock and mountain climbing; the literati adored his physique and fey demeanor. And he was a good guy. Yet Archer has Mallory boldly taking over the Royal Geographic Society's Everest Committee selection process with the commanding forcefulness of a Sergeant Major--qualities he wholly lacked--and boldly leading two Everest expeditions once on the mountain (he was on three). It is true that Mallory was appointed "climbing leader" in 1924, but that position was a mere pat on the back and tightly supervised by Colonel Norton, who was a true leader of men.
While he has Mallory issuing ultimatums to the august governing board left and right, Archer completely leaves out one of Mallory's greatest achievements-- discovering the primary route to the top from the Tibetan side and then being the first human to set foot on Everest's mighty flanks. This first expedition to Mt. Everest--the Reconnaissance Expedition of 1921--is not on Archer's path to glory. This was when Mallory and Guy Bullock almost circumnavigated Everest seeking the best approach to its steep slopes. After five months of the most arduous exploration, Mallory and Bullock finally discovered the hidden eastern side of the North Col at the head of the East Rongbuk Glacier. And it was at the beginning of this expedition, when absolutely nothing was known about the mountain's geography, that Mallory wrote to his wife that "we are about to walk off the map." Of course that phrase is far too evocative to leave out, so Archer merely lifts it to plug into another made-up expedition.
Archer is so enamored with the politically correct Tibetan name for Mt. Everest--"Chomolungma"--that he stuffs it into all the climbers' mouths. But the term was never used by them, and first appeared on Wheeler's 1925 map entitled "Mount Everest and the Chomo-lungma Group." His tin ear is on loudest display when he repeatedly has the taciturn Noel Odell call leader Mallory "skipper."
Probably the most egregious display of political correctness (Does that help sell books nowadays?) is Archer's assertion that his Mallory had actually planned to select as his summit partner not one of the proven RGS climbers, but one of their Sherpa porters with amazing natural climbing abilities! This decision taken when even Australian RGS member George Finch was denied a place on the expedition because he was not English enough. Of course the historical realities were that while Sherpas are genetically endowed with the ability to work hard at high altitude, none of them had climbed mountains before the arrival of the English explorers and their "English air" (oxygen), and they were later taught the skill as ever more expeditions required their services.
The final description of the Mallory and Irvine's climb into history lacks even the faintest patina of reality. They leave their high camp (given as at 27,300-ft--it was actually at 26,800ft) at 5AM carrying eight hours of oxygen. 10-1/2 hours later, they are still breathing the precious gas with presumably some still remaining for their descent. The description of the summit pyramid--available in scores of Everest chronicles, is also a hash. There is no knife-edged ridge after the Second Step, and there is no "vertical rock covered with ice that never melts from year to year" with "112-ft left to climb." And, of course, both men make it to the top before perishing on the descent.
What is the point of this? It is called a novel, but uses actual names, places, and events all twisted into a Disneyesque cartoon. There is no other suggestion that this entire tale is desperately false. To further the deception, Archer prominently credits Audrey Salkeld, a real Everest historian, with "special thanks." Oh how Mrs. Salkeld must feel used!
Finally, a prominent blurb on the jacket of "Paths of Glory" reads "`A storyteller in the class of Alexander Dumas'--The Washington Post." A Google search and a search of the Washington Post's archives could find no such quotation.
Summary of Paths of GlorySome people have dreams that are so magnificent that if they were to achieve them, their place in history would be guaranteed. But what if one man had such a dream?and once he?d fulfilled it, there was no proof that he had achieved his ambition? This is the story of such a man: George Mallory. He once told an American reporter that he wanted to climb Mt. Everest ?because it?s there.? On his third attempt in 1924, at age thirty-seven, he was last seen six hundred feet from the top. His body was found in 1999. And it still remains a mystery whether he ever reached the summit
Family Saga Books
|
 |
Elephant Manby Christine Sparks Ballantine Books; Published: 1986-11-12; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $4.03Price in other shops: $7.99
Assegaiby Wilbur Smith Thomas Dunne Books; Published: 2009-05-12; Hardcover; BookBest price: $1.95Price in other shops: $27.95
Birds of Preyby Wilbur Smith St. Martin's Griffin; Published: 2003-05-16; Paperback; BookBest price: $48.99
An Act of Loveby Nancy Thayer St Martins Pr; Published: 1997-09; Hardcover; BookBest price: $7.85Price in other shops: $22.95
Honoluluby Alan Brennert St. Martin's Press; Published: 2009-03-03; Hardcover; BookBest price: $7.99Price in other shops: $24.95
Family Treeby Barbara Delinsky Anchor; Published: 2009-10-27; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $1.99Price in other shops: $5.99
Those Who Save Usby Jenna Blum Houghton Mifflin Harcourt; Published: 2005-05-02; Paperback; BookBest price: $4.47Price in other shops: $14.95
Vinegar Hillby A. Manette Ansay Penguin USA (P); Published: 2000-05; Paperback; BookBest price: $14.99
Billy Phelan's Greatest Gameby William Kennedy Penguin (Non-Classics); Published: 1983-01-27; Paperback; BookBest price: $4.69Price in other shops: $14.00
Quicksilver (The Baroque Cycle, Vol. 1)by Neal Stephenson William Morrow Paperbacks; Published: 2004-09-21; Paperback; BookBest price: $3.50Price in other shops: $15.99
|
A Quiver Full of Arrowsby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2005-08-30; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $4.43Price in other shops: $7.99
As the Crow Fliesby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2004-05-16; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $5.24Price in other shops: $8.99
The Prodigal Daughterby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2004-05-16; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $5.23Price in other shops: $8.99
Kane and Abelby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2009-11-03; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $4.99Price in other shops: $9.99
First Among Equalsby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2004-05-16; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $4.63Price in other shops: $7.99
False Impressionby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2006-11-28; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $3.00Price in other shops: $9.99
Shall We Tell the President?by Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2008-12-30; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $3.99Price in other shops: $9.99
A Prisoner of Birthby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2008-12-02; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $3.99Price in other shops: $9.99
Not a Penny More, Not a Penny Lessby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2004-05-16; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $4.16Price in other shops: $7.99
A Matter of Honorby Jeffrey Archer St. Martin's Paperbacks; Published: 2004-12-28; Mass Market Paperback; BookBest price: $4.62Price in other shops: $7.99
|