 |
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Colson Whitehead Edition: Hardcover Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Format: Deckle Edge Published: 2009-04-28 ISBN: 0385527659 Number of pages: 288 Publisher: Doubleday
Book Reviews of Sag Harbor: A NovelBook Review: 3 1/2--lots of strong parts but bit too meandering Summary: 3 Stars
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Colson Whitehead's Sag Harbor is a coming-of-age novel set in, well, Sag Harbor, and focusing on 15-yr-old Benji (who tries futilely to get people to now call him Ben). Ben and his brother Reggie have come to Sag Harbor--the section of the Hamptons where many upper-middle class and higher blacks summer--and pretty much have their summer house to themselves as their parents are always promising to be out on the weekend but seldom show.
As evidence by the name change, Benji is trying to remake himself a bit this summer, trying to leave behind the nerdy comic-book reading, Dungeons-and-Dragon's-playing, "ReggienBenji" self and replace it with a more mature Ben who just maybe might do something with a girl, might be thought adequately cool.
And so we move with him through the vacation period--Memorial Day when they "come out" to Labor Day when they head back to the city. It's not a momentous summer--the reader isn't going to be captivated here by the time they burned the house down, or the time a murderer stalked Sag Harbor, or the time . . . Nothing really happens here plot-wise--there's some ice-cream scooping at Benji's job, some beachcombing, a few girls to talk to, a concert.
It's a meandering lazy summer seen through the eyes of a meandering teenager. And to be honest, the book meanders a bit too much. What saves it, though not completely, is Benji's sharply accurate and sometimes funny, sometimes poignant descriptions of his life and the lives of those around him. He often nails the teenager's voice and view of the world: the list of fake smile types (#1 To patronize Grown-ups) or the most common causes of silence in his house (#5 indexing of grudges); the tormented glee (was it an accident or on purpose) of contacting a fully-clothed breast with one's forearm; the power of that one member of the group who has a car and drives; etc.
We get these same sharp moments of racial/social self-awareness, as in a hilarious but thought-provoking riff on why one doesn't walk down the street carrying a watermelon or on the ways the Cosby show (the book is set in 1985) ripples through the black community.
We love Benji's anecdotes, his painful self-awareness; we feel for him when he is dissed by his friends or a new girl or in those lightly-touched upon but emotionally powerful moments when his family's troubles are laid utterly bare, such as when his father hits him repeatedly across the face to teach him to stand up for himself.
Unfortunately, as much as we love and connect to Benji' voice, it doesn't quite carry the novel fully. At times, Whitehead himself falls a bit too in love with his own descriptions, and carries them long past the point where the reader wants to surrender and just get back to the story: four pages on customers at the ice cream shop, overly-lengthy descriptions of his father's barbecuing. Each individual paragraph is in itself strong writing, but many times one wishes he had saved some of them for another book.
So pacing is a problem--the book feels long, like when you walk out of a 90 minute movie that felt like two hours, even if you enjoyed the scene at the start, and that other one in the middle, and so on. And it feels a bit unbalanced in its presentation of the light and the not-so-light and the not-light-at-all. Everything is important to a teenager, but some things remain more important than others, and so those moments when his father's brutal anger pops up--either in the above mentioned scene or a chillingly tense scene with between Benji's mother and father, as a reader you'd like those scenes to have a bit more heft in their presentation instead of being just another moment of "what I did this summer."
As much as I laughed out loud or quietly at many parts, reacted with sorrow or empathy at others, I had to push myself to finish the book; I just needed more than what I was getting. The good news is that if you do get to the end, there penultimate section is simply beautifully written--emotionally dense and moving and poetic. It's all the sharply accurate and vivid description that came before but put to a honed purpose. The ending itself is OK, a bit predictable for what the type of book this is, and I found myself wishing he had ended it twenty pages sooner.
Overall I give the book a 3 1/2 mostly due to its pacing problem and meandering lightness that robbed it of being a compelling read. Take out 50-60 pages and this would have been a lovely, funny, poignant novel. Recommended, but a bit half-heartedly.
Summary of Sag Harbor: A NovelThe warm, funny, and supremely original new novel from one of the most acclaimed writers in America The year is 1985. Benji Cooper is one of the only black students at an elite prep school in Manhattan. He spends his falls and winters going to roller-disco bar mitzvahs, playing too much Dungeons and Dragons, and trying to catch glimpses of nudity on late-night cable TV. After a tragic mishap on his first day of high school?when Benji reveals his deep enthusiasm for the horror movie magazine Fangoria?his social doom is sealed for the next four years.
But every summer, Benji escapes to the Hamptons, to Sag Harbor, where a small community of African American professionals have built a world of their own. Because their parents come out only on weekends, he and his friends are left to their own devices for three glorious months. And although he?s just as confused about this all-black refuge as he is about the white world he negotiates the rest of the year, he thinks that maybe this summer things will be different. If all goes according to plan, that is.
There will be trials and tribulations, of course. There will be complicated new handshakes to fumble through, and state-of-the-art profanity to master. He will be tested by contests big and small, by his misshapen haircut (which seems to have a will of its own), by the New Coke Tragedy of ?85, and by his secret Lite FM addiction. But maybe, with a little luck, things will turn out differently this summer.
In this deeply affectionate and fiercely funny coming-of-age novel, Whitehead?using the perpetual mortification of teenage existence and the desperate quest for reinvention?lithely probes the elusive nature of identity, both personal and communal. Amazon Best of the Month, May 2009: Like his fellow New Yorker Jonathan Lethem, Colson Whitehead weaves gracefully through genres with each of his books, but Sag Harbor, billed as his "autobiographical fourth novel," seems positioned to be his breakout book--which is a funny thing for a writer who has already received so many major literary awards, including a MacArthur "Genius" grant and being short-listed for the Pulitzer. The year is 1985 and 15-year-old Benji Cooper, one of the only black students at his elite Manhattan private school, leaves the city to spend three largely unsupervised months living with his younger brother Reggie in an enclave of Long Island's Sag Harbor, the summer home to many African American urban professionals. Benji's a Converse-wearing, Smiths-loving, Dungeons & Dragons-playing nerd whose favorite Star Wars character is the hapless bounty hunter Greedo (rather than the double-crossing Lando Calrissian). But Sag Harbor is a coming-of-age novel whose plot side-steps life-changing events writ large. The book's leisurely eight chapters mostly concern Benji's first kiss, the removal of braces, BB gun battles, slinging insults (largely unprintable "grammatical acrobatics") with his friends, and working his first summer job. And Whitehead crafts a wonderful set piece describing Benji's days at Jonni Waffle Ice Cream, where he is shrouded in "waffle musk" and a dirty T-shirt that's "soiled, covered with batter and befudged from a sundae mishap." Whitehead pushes his love of pop culture into hyper-drive. Nearly every page is swimming with references to the 1980s--from New Coke and The Cosby Show to late nights trying to decipher flickering glimpses of naked women on scrambled Cinemax. And music courses through the book, capturing that period when early hip hop mixed with New Wave. Lisa Lisa and U.T.F.O make a memorable cameo at Jonni Waffle, and McFadden & Whitehead's "Ain't No Stoppin' Us Now"--heard throughout the book in passing cars and boom boxes--gets tagged as "the black national anthem." Like that ubiquitous song, the soulful, celebratory, and painfully funny Sag Harbor and its chronicle of those lazy, sun-soaked days sandwiched between Memorial Day and Labor Day, will stick with you long after closing its covers. --Brad Thomas Parsons Amazon Exclusive: Jonathan Lethem Reviews Sag Harbor
Jonathan Lethem's new novel, Chronic City, will be published in October 2009, and is his first to be set in Manhattan. He is the author of seven novels including the New York Times bestseller The Fortress of Solitude, which was also a New York Times Book Review Editors Choice for 2003, and Motherless Brooklyn, which won the National Book Critics Circle Award in 1999. A recipient of a MacArthur Fellowship, his stories and essays have appeared in The New Yorker, Harper's, Rolling Stone, Esquire, and the New York Times among others. He lives in Brooklyn, New York, and Maine.  First, an immodest disclaimer: I knew Colson Whitehead was really, really good before you did. That's because we share a publisher, and an editor, and I was sent a copy of his first novel, The Intuitionist, and asked to give advance comment--"a pufferoon," as insiders affectionately call the things--which I gladly did. In fact, I not only admired The Intuitionist, but it was a book that made me immediately feel less lonely. I'd published four novels at that point, and Colson's helped me to feel my particular approach, the sorts of things I was trying to pull off in my novels, wasn't absolutely misconceived. In fact, I wanted to hitch my wagon to Colson's obvious rising star; his first novel was more flawless, more accomplished, than my own first--it might have been more accomplished than my fourth, I wasn't sure. I immediately sought Colson out as a friend, and he's been one of my own most crucial peers ever since. Colson's books are all quite different from one another in milieu, strategy, and their ultimate effect on the reader, though united by the signal laconic meter in his voice, by their keen sense of form and proportion, by their brilliance. In Sag Harbor he's "gone personal," though I wouldn't want to have to place bets on what is and isn't his own life-material here, or someone else's, or completely confabulated. This is one of my favorite kinds of books, where memory's kinesthetic floodgates open up to illuminate a lost world. It's like a meticulous diorama of the recent past, with the sharp edges of an exhibit in a museum, one where we learn just how strange and specific the universal experience of "coming of age" really can be. The mundane stuff of a Long Island summer here has the power both of a time capsule, and of an allegorical journey into what every human heart endures just trying to vault out of one's family and into the world of art, sex, and kinship that's so near, and so far off. All this, plus the greatest barbequed chicken wing in the history of literature past, present, or future. That's a pufferoon I'd guarantee with my life. --Jonathan Lethem More from Colson Whitehead
Set over the summer of 1985, Sag Harbor, the fourth book from award-winning writer Colson Whitehead, is steeped in 1980s pop culture. Music plays a vital role in the novel, and in this exclusive annotated playlist Whitehead compiles a lineup of nine essential tracks of the early MTV era, including highlights from The Smiths, Run DMC, Bauhaus, and Doug E Fresh and Slick Rick.
And read our interview with Colson Whitehead as we talk about Sag Harbor and discuss some pop culture hits and misses from the 1980s, grilling tips, McFadden & Whitehead, 12-sided die, and the allure of Twitter.
Humor Books
|
 |