 |
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Jacquelyn Mitchard Edition: Paperback Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Published: 2008-07-03 ISBN: 0446696730 Number of pages: 336 Publisher: Grand Central Publishing
Book Reviews of Still SummerBook Review: Intriguing Story, Too Many Errors Summary: 2 Stars
Remember when the teacher told you to "never judge a book by its cover?" Now I do, but when I bought this book I did not. I report to you that I paid the consequences by reading a book fraught with errors and improbabilities making the suspension of disbelief impossible.
The plot sounds intriguing, four middle aged friends plan a Caribbean holiday aboard a crewed charter. The back cover promises us a "desparate fight for survival" as the women "battle the elements, the threats of modern day piracy, and their own frailties." Sounds intriguing enough to occupy a summer's afternoon or two on the annual cruise. As I began to read the book, the first words I read were in the Acknowledgements, it was then that I realized my afternoon might not go so well. Mitchard writes, "This is a work of fiction. The author is neither a sailor nor a geographer [uh-oh], and the events described in this book might not have happened exactly how and when where they did in the fictional world. [huh?]" If these events did not happen in the fictional world, where did they happen? One thing for certain, the author spends the next 300 or so pages proving that she is neither a sailor nor a geographer. Heck, I don't think she every looked a map of the Caribbean! And when was the last time you "yanked on your jib?" Before roller furling, I always hanked on my jib. Or perhaps this was a Freudian slip?
To be certain, the plot was interesting, the characters ones with which you could identify (especially if you're a middle aged woman), and the writing skilled enough to build sufficient tension to keep the reader reading. But, and here's a big but, if you're a sailor, if you have some knowledge of the Caribbean, you will repeatedly stumble over the inaccuracies in the book and in the story. It didn't need to be this way, if Mitchard had only done her homework a little better. If only her editor had given the book to a sailor before publishing. If only Mitchard had gone down to the Chicago Yacht Club and asked for some advice, we'd have a better story for sailors and everyone else. The errors are many, detracting from what could have been a great story. And then there are the loose ends, dangling like participles from a poorly formed sentence and too numerous to report here.
If only I had remembered my teacher's lesson.
Dave Lochner
NauticalReads
Summary of Still SummerThe New York Times bestselling author of returns with a breathtaking tale of suspense and high adventure.
In high school, Olivia, Tracy and Holly had been known as The Godmothers, and their friendship has endured throughout the ensuing decades. Now, with the death of Olivia's husband, a wealthy Italian Count, and her return to America, the friends decide to reunite on a luxury cruise in the Caribbean. Along with Tracy's college-aged daughter and a two-man crew, they begin their journey uneventfully, enjoying the sun and the warm, clear waters of the Caribbean. Then, a series of devastating events unfolds, leaving the women crewless, starving and terrified. Almost overnight, what was meant to be a blissful vacation devolves into a desperate fight for survival, as they soon find themselves battling the elements, a horrifying attack by drug traffickers, and their own frailties. It is at once a story about the bonds of friendship, the love between mothers and their children, and the strengths we don't know we possess until we are faced with our own mortality. Guest Reviewer: Jodi Picoult From the provocative and gut-wrenching The Pact, to the brilliant genre-bending The Tenth Circle, to Nineteen Minutes, her most recent novel about a high-school shooting, Jodi Picoult's riveting novels center on family and relationships, and bring to light questions and issues that remain with a reader long after the last page is turned. In one of my novels, I describe life as what happens when the what-if's don't. In Jacquelyn Mitchard's book, Still Summer, we lucky readers get tumbled into a world where extraordinary things happen to ordinary women; where the what-if's don't only become a reality, but a nightmare that truly puts into perspective what's important in life, and who we truly are.
Mitchard has always excelled at capturing the details of a fictional character with such a finely drawn hand that it's easy to believe you know the people who inhabit her books--that you may have had coffee with them, or passed them on the street. Sometimes her characters are so real to me I have to close the book to cry; or I find myself yelling at them out loud. The ladies of Still Summer--a band of high-school friends who have long since grown up--base their connection to each other on the past, when they were tough-talking Catholic schoolgirls called the Godmothers. But where Tracy, Holly, and Janis went on to marry and live quiet suburban lives, Olivia became an Italian countess, living the kind of life the others could only dream about. Reunited for a Caribbean sailing voyage after Olivia's husband's death, we watch the women come to terms with the fact that our memories of the past are often colored by nostalgia; that friends who fit together seamlessly years ago might, with the passing of time, find it harder to align. The book begins in familiar territory--women whose lives that are peppered with recalcitrant kids, clueless husbands, the double-handed shuffle of home and career. At the last minute, Janis begs out of the trip to tend to an ailing husband--leaving Tracy's daughter, Cammie, to take her place--in spite of the fact that the relationship between mother and daughter is rocky and cavernous. And then, just as suddenly as a rogue wind, the book takes a shocking turn--leaving these women in a crisis situation that leaves them not only fighting for their lives, but revising their own understanding of friendship, family, and loyalty. What is it about a Mitchard novel that rises so far above others? The realism, the grace of the characters who people it, and the heartbreaking truths that sneak up on a reader when we least expect it. Still Summer reminds us that sometimes it takes a tragedy to learn what's beautiful about ordinary life; that sometimes we have to travel great distances to figure out how we define "home"; and perhaps most importantly, that we do not know anyone as well as we think--not our daughters, not our friends, and not even ourselves. --Jodi Picoult
Action & Adventure Books
|
 |