 |
The Accidental President of Brazil: A Memoir by Fernando Cardoso
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Fernando Cardoso Preface: Bill Clinton Edition: Hardcover Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Published: 2006-03-13 ISBN: 1586483242 Number of pages: 312 Publisher: PublicAffairs
Book Reviews of The Accidental President of Brazil: A MemoirBook Review: Great opening... trails off slow and unfulfilling in the end... Summary: 4 Stars
let's use some soccer (football) analogy. this book is like a football game. first 20 minutes of the game was extremely interesting and filled with surprises and excitement, second 25 minutes continued to be interesting but less so, as if the game has topped out. after intermission, the second half of the game became stale and flat, as if the players lost interest and just hung out on the field and let the clock run out. readers are left with yearning for more.
may be football is not the best analogy as President Cordoso admitted that he does not really like soccer and in fact, he did not watch much soccer. i supposed as an avid reader, he would rather read a book than watching soccer. in fact, reading this book, the distinct impression is that President Cordoso is more of a member of Brasil's intelligentia class than a politician or sociologist. i say this with great respect as throughout the book, tremendous amount of ink was expensed in illustrating how the President, duing his youth and adult life engaged and enjoyed doing the intellect thing (late night political discussion, intellectual dialectic on the beach, writing his thesis for think tank etc). the impression is even during President Cordoso's political life (mayoral, senate and finally presidential), he was more an academician or scholar than a politician. this is distinctively different from my impression of Ronald Reagan or Bill Clinton who are no less smart but portrayed themselves as a common Joe Blow, in Reagan's case, a supposedly farm boy from the midwest and Bill Clinton, a poor white boy from the south. In President Cordoso's case, he was a intellect, scholar from a powerful family.
despite coming from a powerful family, the President is an extremely humble person as one can read throughout the book. due to this, i developed a tremendous respect for the President. i also admired the President for admitting that Brasil has big racial problem and that while Brasil presents itself to the world as a "white' country, in reality, it is more a "black" country (as 45% of Brasilians are of african descent). this is great honesty. my disappointment is, the President only achieved half of the success he set for himself in addressing racial inequality during his 8-year tenure. by the President's own admission, even the prestigeous USP refused to establish an affirmative action program to accept African Brasilian students. finally, i also like the easy going presentation of the President who discussed contemporary brasilian history in the most story telling way. as a non brasilian who did not know anything about brasil's history, the President's descriptive of Brasil's transformation from a colony to Republic is distinctively clear, easy to understand and most of all, extremely interesting. this is the best highlight of this book.
now the lowlight. the President did not discuss much about the Cold War. he downplayed Ronald Reagan's Evil Empire and Freedom principle. in fact, the President never mentioned Reagan's contribution to the Cold War but attributed the downfall of the Soviet Empire as if this was a chinese Yin/Yan turning of the tide during a mystical cycle. the President has his own ideology ground to cover, i can appreciate that but also disagree with him. however, the great disappointment to me was the President did not discuss some critical element about the military era of Brasil. we know he went into exile and his family suffered, he also lost some of his best friends as the military regime created disappearance of these folks. however, the President never wrote about the big elephant in the room, i.e. who were the military elements? names of the players? what did the military do to brasil (other than imprisoning or murdering the intellectual class and other opposition elements, putting brasil out of democracy). i am interested to know the President's personal view of those military Generals? he did expressed his view (disapproval) of US under Nixon's support of the military regime. OK, so Nixon as in US, but who are these military, who is xyz to the military regime? where are they now? what are they doing now? on behalf of the nation, the President apologized and paid indemnity to the victims but were the culprits brought to justice or were they applied the "forgivenss brasilian style"? we don't know after reading this book. does the President still consider them a threat to Brasil's democracy? the book never addressed this. this is the most disappointing part of the book. finally, the book gave me a distinctive impression that in Brasil, the common folks are DOWN THERE and the intellectuals are UP THERE, playing the role of the savior attemtping to save those DOWN THERE. may be this style works in Brasil to attract the vote. i remember my mid level brasilian colleague who told me he has fresh OJ squeezed for him every morning by his maid..... the UP THERE/DOWN THERE thing?
so, all in all. a very interesting book although i wish the book can go a little furthermore.
Summary of The Accidental President of Brazil: A MemoirFernando Henrique Cardoso received a phone call in the middle of the night asking him to be the new Finance Minister of Brazil. As he put the phone down and stared into the darkness of his hotel room, he feared he'd been handed a political death sentence. The year was 1993, and he would be responsible for an economy that had had seven different currencies in the previous eight years to cope with inflation that had run at 3000 percent a year. Brazil had a habit of chewing up finance ministers with the ferocity of an Amazon piranha. This was just one of the turns in a largely unscripted and sometimes unwanted political career. In exile during the harshest period of the junta that ruled Brazil for twenty years, Cardoso started his political life with a tentative run for the Federal Senate in 1978. Within fifteen years, and despite himself, this former sociologist was running the country. And what a country! Brazil, it is often said, is on the edge of modernity, striding with one foot in mid-air towards the future, the other still rooted deep in a traditional past. It is a land of sophisticated music and brutal gold-digging, of the next global superpower and the last old-time coffee plantations. It is gloriously ungovernable, irrepressibly attractive, and home to the family, friends and extraordinary life of Fernando Henrique Cardoso. This is his story and his love song to his country.
Political Books
|
 |