 |
The Wisdom of Menopause: Creating Physical and Emotional Health and Healing During the Change, Revised Edition by Christiane Northrup
Book Summary InformationAuthor: Christiane Northrup Brand: PBS Edition: Paperback Audio: English (Unknown); English (Original Language); English (Published) Published: 2006-10-31 ISBN: 0553384090 Number of pages: 656 Publisher: Bantam
Book Reviews of The Wisdom of Menopause: Creating Physical and Emotional Health and Healing During the Change, Revised EditionBook Review: Revised Edition Still has Bad Advice Summary: 2 Stars
I posted similar info seen here in a different review, about Dr. John Lee's book "What Your Doctor May NOT Tell You About Menopause", which is a significantly better book than this one, in every respect.
Dr. Christiane Northrup has become the magical menopausal Yoda for a generation. Although I do have her books and suggest that women read them, the advice they contain are not The End of All Information. I really have to say that Dr. John Lee's books are better than Northrup's in terms of actual practical and clinical information. I followed HIS advice, not hers (which is convoluted at times, and plain out dangerous at others) and that's how I got better. And I have to say I am deeply disappointed that in this revised 2006 paperback edition of "The Wisdom of Menopause" that Northrup continues to urge women to eat soy products as a phytoestrogenic assist to their menopausal symptoms.
Soy as it is processed in the USA is basically unhealthy. (For more info on the power of the U.S. soybean industry and lobby, see Dr. Mary Eng's books, especially "Eat Fat/Lose Fat"...a stupid catchy title that the publisher insisted upon, but the book's main focus is on the history of the evils of dietary liquid oil--specifically soybean oil--and the benefits of the so-called "bad" fats like coconut oil and butter. The book is available here on Amazon, as well as Michael Pollan's books on food, etc.)
In addition to soy's phytoestrogenic effects--feminizing effects which men and boys are exposed to in huge numbers because Americans now eat more soy than any other country in the world--soy also has phytic acid, that among other things contributes to thyroid and lipid disorders, and, much worse and more quickly, binds to essential minerals like Magnesium and thereby blocks nutrient absorption. American women suffer in epidemic proportions from low levels of Magnesium and Vitamin D, which contributes to osteoporosis despite the "epidemic additions" of calcium to our food products and our faithful usage of calcium supplements.
Yes, soy does have phytoestrogenic properties, but the phytic acid creates a huge nutritional and endocrine depletion. The soy found in soy milk and the soy protein isolates found in every high-protein product on the market from cereals like Kashi and others to on-the-go granola-type bars and food replacement/body builder power shakes is plain and simply bad for you. Soy must be either soaked or fermented to render out the phytic acid, as happens when it is made into tofu, miso, tempeh or soy sauce. This is solely how soy is eaten in Asia. Asians eat soy as a mere condiment, not as a protein substitute, which is how Americans have come to use it. As I said earlier: the U.S. now uses more soy than any other country on earth. So the American soybean industry has a great deal at stake in promoting the supposed health benefits of their product, don't they?
So when people like Christiane Northrup--and dare I say it--the soybean industry and lobby--talk about the health benefits of soy and point to the fact that Asians historically have lower levels of breast and uterine cancer and that soy does not have feminizing effects on their men--they are not talking about the reality of American soy. Asians eat small quantities of properly prepared soy that removes phytic acid and leaves the phytoestrogens intact, and Asian men simply do not eat enough soy to have feminization issues--in fact, the average Japanese eats a mere 2 tablespoons of soy per day, and all of it is fermented or soaked... All soy in all American food products is cooked quickly at high temperatures--not fermented or soaked--and the heat does not effect the phytic acid levels the least little bit. Phytic acid is still active in every single glass of soy milk Dr. Northrup urges you drink for your menopausal symptoms and in every power bar you shove into your purse as you run out the door on the way to work. End result? You're actually contributing to your own health problems by trying to do the right thing. And Dr. Northrup--a woman--must surely know better than this by now, but she hasn't said a word about the soy contradiction. She apparently will not admit that she is wrong--just like the typical establishment professional she professes not to be.
Given that I suffer from alopecia I am appalled that in the 2006 revised edition of this book that she didn't amend or change her poor advice for women who have the thinning hair that accompanies menopause. The 2006 book still mentions the toxic drugs I was on for my alopecia: birth control pills and Spironolactone. For a woman who is known for her "natural" viewpoint and her affiliation with the bio-identical hormone movement, Northrup could at least remove the list of drugs, and change the paragraph that prefaces the medication list to read "there are synthetic medications I do not endorse that temporarily stave off androgenic hair loss. If you are interested in this line of treatment, consult your practitioner" or words to that effect. I don't think that's so hard to say. The 2006 book still has a list of toxic, man-made synthetic drugs that she herself does not recommend, and this goes against Northrup's well-publicized credo of "help heal yourself by using your own internal wisdom."
Northrup has made her name by professing to have an anti-medical establishment viewpoint, so why does she continue to mention these synthetic drugs? And...to deepen this insult, Northrup continues to blithely suggest that alopecia sufferers "use gentle shampoos, don't brush your hair, and use volumizers." Gimme a break. All women with thinning hair have spent countless hours doing research. We know every trick in the book and we've spent tons of money on everything under the sun to deal with our hair loss.
But guess what? The wonderful Dr. John Lee lets us know in his book (title above) that bio-identical progesterone cream WILL HELP BEGIN NEW HAIR GROWTH in 3-4 months. Why didn't Dr. Northrup talk about this? She supposedly knows all about natural progesterone cream. So Dr. Lee's info that progesterone cream helps hair loss turns out to be BIG NEWS. I can tell you that the hair loss triggered by quitting my alopecia/HRT meds cold turkey has abated completely. I'm now losing just the normal 40-100 hairs per day, and I've got baby hairs growing again at my temples, which is where most of my hair fell out in the first place. Time will tell if I get back all the hair I lost, but at least it stopped falling out.
Read this book, but really--buy Dr. John Lee's books, and you'll get more usable info.
Summary of The Wisdom of Menopause: Creating Physical and Emotional Health and Healing During the Change, Revised EditionThrough her bestselling books, groundbreaking PBS specials, and up-to-the-minute clinical knowledge, Dr. Christiane Northrup has earned a place as one of America?s most trusted medical advisors.
In The Wisdom of Menopause, she once again challenges convention with this inspiring look at one of the most commonly misunderstood female health issues. The ?change? is not simply a collection of physical symptoms to be ?fixed,? Dr. Northrup claims, but a mind/body revolution that brings the greatest opportunity for growth since adolescence. The choices a woman makes now?from the quality of her relationships to the quality of her diet?have the power to secure her health and well-being for the rest of her life. Through her personal story and many fascinating case histories, Dr. Northrup shows:
? How menopause jump-starts changes in the brain, issuing a dramatic wake-up call to body, mind, and emotions ? How to ensure the long-term health of breasts, bones, and heart ? How the body adjusts naturally to changing hormones ? Why bestselling drugs like Premarin may not be the best choice ? How to deal with metabolism shifts, weight gain, sexual problems, and appearance issues ? How to negotiate the challenges of ?the empty nest? and midlife marriage
And much more.
In a book destined to be a classic, Dr. Northrup shows women how they can make menopause a time of personal empowerment and positive energy?emerging wiser, healthier, and stronger in both mind and body than ever before. Menopause doesn't have to be a dreaded curse of aging during which we can look forward only to hot flashes and whacked-out hormonal mood swings. According to Christiane Northrup, M.D. (Women's Bodies, Women's Wisdom), menopause often marks the beginning of a woman's most sexually passionate, creatively inspired, and professionally productive phase of life. While this may sound like wishful thinking, Northrup backs up her good news with solid medical expertise. As an obstetrician and gynecologist, Northrup has specialized in using a mind-body approach to women's health for decades, which means she doesn't just write about hormones, but also examines how a woman's lifestyle, emotions, and beliefs are affected by menopause. With the right diet, attitude, and perhaps some supplements along the way, women can actually look forward to a resurgence of energy and a revolutionary opportunity for personal growth--one that rivals the hormonally driven period of adolescence in its scope and urgency, she claims. And yes, at just under 500 pages, The Wisdom of Menopause does explain how to have a positive and healthy menopause in concise detail. Northrup has indeed "written the book" on menopause. It helps that Northrup has been through menopause herself (she vowed she wouldn't write a book on it until she was on the other side). Readers have the sense that they are gleaning advice from a knowledgeable holistic doctor as well as a sage aunt whose life was radically altered by the "change of life" (Northrup divorced at the onset of menopause). After she shares her personal story of "the change," Northrup delves into a significant discussion on how self-sacrifice catches up with women in midlife. Suddenly, hormones are directing women out of the caregiver role and into an inwardly focused assessment of life and its meaning, she explains. Resentments (not hormones) are what spur the notorious surges of anger, as women reexamine the agreements surrounding their relationships with colleagues, friends, and family members. From here, Northrup guides readers into a thorough section on menopausal hormone changes--a discussion that is scientifically informative, yet entirely accessible. While acknowledging the need for hormone-replacement therapy and the tremendous relief it can provide (helping to alleviate insomnia, hot flashes, and depression), Northrup encourages women to avoid synthetic hormones and instead consider "bioidentical" hormones (such as estradiol, estrone, and estriol). She also devotes an entire chapter to foods and supplements that support hormonal balance. By the way, she says to skip the wild Mexican yam creams: "they certainly don't provide the documented benefits of progesterone." Be warned: some readers may find the advice in Wisdom of Menopause too alternative for their liking. For example, in her discussion on insomnia, one of Northrup's recommendations is to cover the mirror at night, following the ancient Asian design principles of feng shui. (Skeptics will find Northrup's medical assertions carefully cited and footnoted in the rear of her book.) Northrup gives a solid and practical diet plan that supports hormonal balance while countering the weight gain that so frequently plagues menopausal women ("focus on portion size, not calories," "eat protein at every meal," and cut down on refined and high-carbohydrate foods). Readers can also expect a thorough mind-body discussion in subsequent chapters that cover breast health, bone loss, and cultivating midlife beauty, along with chapters titled "Sex and Menopause: Myths and Reality" and "Creating Pelvic Health and Power." She concludes with a list of mail-order and online resources, such as retailers for bioidentical hormones, progesterone cream, Chinese herbs, soy products, weight-loss audiocassettes, lubricants, and Kegel weights. Northrup takes a truly comprehensive approach to all the effective treatments of menopausal symptoms so that women can make their own highly informed and wise choices. --Gail Hudson
Women's Health Books
|
 |