 |
Until Proven Innocent: Political Correctness and the Shameful Injustices of the Duke Lacrosse Rape Case by KC Johnson, Stuart Taylor Jr.
Book Summary InformationAuthor: KC Johnson, Stuart Taylor Jr. Edition: Hardcover Audio: English (Original Language); English (Unknown); English (Published) Published: 2007-09-04 ISBN: 0312369123 Number of pages: 432 Publisher: Thomas Dunne Books
Book Reviews of Until Proven Innocent: Political Correctness and the Shameful Injustices of the Duke Lacrosse Rape CaseBook Review: pretty mind-blowing Summary: 3 StarsI got a lot out of this book. The reason I'm giving it only three stars is that in doing so I'm attempting to distinguish between my monumental sense of things finally being righted (the evildoers exposed, the just exonerated, etc.) from what is just Taylor and Johnson's retelling of the affair in this book.
What I mean is that it's tempting to award five stars for something that, when you get right down to it, is no more than my personal feeling of grand satisfaction with the way the affair turned out, the way one is reassured at the end of most of Shakespeare's tragedies. But when I cast a more skeptical eye at the way this book introduces, covers, and resolves the Duke scandal, I must aver the following shortcomings:
1. There are no footnotes! I understand this would have added a whopping section at the end, but considering that the authors frequently write things like "sources claim that" and "according to one witness," their not listing their sources must be accounted a major defect. There were several times reading this where I wanted to track down a primary source the authors referred to, but since there's zilch for a reference section, I didn't even know where to begin. Even a crummy Wikipedia article is better sourced than this text.
2. Lord, there were a lot of people involved in this: hundreds and hundreds. There should have been a glossary, or list of characters, or something at the end with the basic facts about each one for ready review. Instead, dozens of pages after introducing a character, the authors think nothing of referring to him again merely by his last name, causing no end of confusion. This should have been seen to somehow.
3. Another reviewer notes that this book is "repetitive." Yup. Could have been a lot shorter. I can't see any need for the last three chapters, for example.
4. This book needed about five times more pictures than it had. Why were they so stingy in this regard?
5. But the biggest problem I saw was a more systemic one with the way the book was apparently written. From what I could make out, the authors were bloggers who, after the dust had settled on the case, went back into their archives and pieced the text together. Because if you take this as investigative journalism, it's awfully lazy. There appear to be very few in-person interviews: instead the authors merely shoot off emails here and there. Key locales in the story were apparently never personally visited by the authors in person. This book is pretty impressive for being built of internet searches, emails, and phone calls, but I got the feeling there was a lot more they could have done.
Despite all this, I feel somewhat guilty awarding only three stars: it really shook me up and amazed me. Any book like that would normally get five.
Incidentally, this book helped to cement my relief that I never became a college professor, something many people enjoined me to do when I was younger. Reading about the shameful antics of the Duke faculty, I'm doubly grateful now I never entered the academy. What looniness!
Summary of Until Proven Innocent: Political Correctness and the Shameful Injustices of the Duke Lacrosse Rape CaseWhat began that night shocked Duke University and Durham, North Carolina. And it continues to captivate the nation: the Duke lacrosse team members? alleged rape of an African-American stripper and the unraveling of the case against them. In this ever-deepening American tragedy, Stuart Taylor Jr. and KC Johnson argue, law enforcement, a campaigning prosecutor, biased journalists, and left-leaning academics repeatedly refused to pursue the truth while scapegoats were made of these young men, recklessly tarnishing their lives. The story harbors multiple dramas, including the actions of a DA running for office; the inappropriate charges that should have been apparent to academics at Duke many months ago; the local and national media, who were so slow to take account of the publicly available evidence; and the appalling reactions of law enforcement, academia, and many black leaders. Until Proven Innocent is the only book that covers all five aspects of the case (personal, legal, academic, political, and media) in a comprehensive fashion. Based on interviews with key members of the defense team, many of the unindicted lacrosse players, and Duke officials, it is also the only book to include interviews with all three of the defendants, their families, and their legal teams. Taylor and Johnson?s coverage of the Duke case was the earliest, most honest, and most comprehensive in the country, and here they take the idiocies and dishonesty of right- and left-wingers alike head on, shedding new light on the dangers of rogue prosecutors and police and a cultural tendency toward media-fueled travesties of justice. The context of the Duke case has vast import and contains likable heroes, unfortunate victims, and memorable villains?and in its full telling, it is captivating nonfiction with broad political, racial, and cultural relevance to our times.
Rape Books
|
 |
May I Kiss You? A Candid Look at Dating, Communication, Respect, & Sexual Assault Awarenessby Michael J. Domitrz Awareness Publications; Published: 2003-03-27; Paperback; BookBest price: $3.90Price in other shops: $15.95
Hours of Torture, Years of Silence : My Soul Was the Scene of the Crimeby Teresa Lauer RapeRecovery.com; Published: 1998-02-01; Paperback; BookBest price: $9.89Price in other shops: $14.95
The Wrong Guys: Murder, False Confessions, and the Norfolk Fourby Tom Wells, Richard Leo New Press; Published: 2008-11-03; Hardcover; BookBest price: $16.36Price in other shops: $25.95
Surviving the Silence: Black Women's Stories of Rapeby Charlotte Pierce-Baker W. W. Norton & Company; Published: 1998-09; Hardcover; BookBest price: $17.70Price in other shops: $23.95
Hidden Joy in a Dark Corner: The Transforming Power of God's Storyby Wendy Blight Moody Publishers; Published: 2009-02-01; Paperback; BookBest price: $1.59Price in other shops: $13.99
Yes Means Yes: Visions of Female Sexual Power and A World Without Rapeby Jaclyn Friedman, Jessica Valenti Seal Press; Published: 2008-12-01; Paperback; BookBest price: $10.00Price in other shops: $16.95
Telling: A Memoir of Rape and Recoveryby Patricia Weaver Francisco HarperCollins; Published: 1999-02-01; Hardcover; BookBest price: $3.00Price in other shops: $23.00
Exit to Freedomby Calvin C. Johnson Jr., Greg Hampikian University of Georgia Press; Published: 2003-09-15; Hardcover; BookBest price: $9.00Price in other shops: $28.95
Shattered : Reclaiming a Life Torn Apart by Violenceby Debra Puglisi Sharp, Debra Sharp Atria; Published: 2003-08-01; Hardcover; BookBest price: $16.54Price in other shops: $25.00
After Silence: Rape & My Journey Backby Nancy Venable Raine Three Rivers Press; Published: 1999-08-03; Paperback; BookBest price: $7.20Price in other shops: $16.00
|
|